Altcoin

Mimblewimble Privacy Isn’t ‘Fundamentally Flawed’

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

The developers of privacy-centric cryptocurrency Grin (GRIN) have hit back at the fundamental claims of an article purporting to have “broken” the coin’s privacy model.

In a Medium blog post published on Nov. 19, Grin core dev Daniel Lehnberg argued that the so-called breakage did not go beyond the already-acknowledged privacy limitations of the coin’s protocol and relied on a passive attack vector that would be insufficient to glean actionable data.

Some basics of Grin’s protocol

Lehnberg’s post does not consist of a point-by-point takedown of the original article, which was published yesterday by Ivan Bogatyy, a researcher at United States-based Dragonfly Capital Partners. 

Instead, it targets what it deems to be the purportedly unsubstantiated logical leaps and factual inaccuracies used by Bogatyy to corroborate his claim. 

As previously reported, Grin’s protocol “Mimblewimble” is a variant of the cryptographic protocol known as Confidential Transactions, which uses cryptographic primitives known as “Pedersen commitments.” 

These obfuscate sensitive transaction data rather than showing plaintext transaction values and can, therefore, prevent double-spending while improving privacy. They allow for the use of basic arithmetic using public parameters to validate transactions, while the correspondent transaction input and output values remain unknown variables.

The protocol notably does not use wallet addresses or public keys, only inputs and outputs. Because of this, each sender must contact a receiver via a private channel in order to construct a transaction.

Supplemental privacy features

As outlined in Cointelegraph’s coverage yesterday, Bogatyy had focused on the use of a default, supplemental feature to MimbleWimble called CoinJoin, which creates small “anonymity sets” by combining encrypted inputs into a single large transaction in such a way as to make it is difficult to distinguish which inputs are paying which outputs. 

Bogatyy also claimed to have conducted a successful “attack” on a supplemental feature called “Dandelion” that is used by Grin to reduce the chance of so-called “spy nodes” recording transactions before cut-through, while they are still in an unconfirmed transaction pool (or “mempool”). 

While the limitations of Grin’s overall privacy model — which is significantly more complex than space permits to outline here — are known, Lehnberg’s critique of Bogatyy’s research rests on what he judges to be key “inconsistencies.”

These include the implication that it would be possible for law enforcement to link intercepted data to a user address — when, as Lehnberg states, addresses do not exist within Grin’s privacy model at all. He adds: 

“We have to assume that the author conveniently confused transaction outputs (TXOs) with addresses, but these are not the same. And, as we’ve already detailed, the fact that TXOs can be linked is hardly news.”

Lehnberg’s critique of Bogatyy’s claims continues to address several further points, with his central line of argument — details aside — resting on the statement that:

“The Grin team has consistently acknowledged that Grin’s privacy is far from perfect. While transaction linkability is a limitation that we’re looking to mitigate as part of our goal of ever-improving privacy, it does not ‘break’ Mimblewimble nor is it anywhere close to being so fundamental as to render it or Grin’s privacy features useless.”

Recent developments

As reported, Grin underwent its first network hard-fork this summer to introduce tweaks to its consensus algorithm in order to achieve greater resistance to ASIC miners.

In October, the Litecoin Foundation published two new draft proposals that pave the way toward integrating MimbleWimble in order to establish privacy features for the Litecoin (LTC) network.

Earlier this month, Grin received an anonymous 50 Bitcoin (BTC) donation to its General Fund, sparking a bizarre rumor that the generous soul behind it was Satoshi.





Source

Leave a Reply

avatar
  Subscribe  
Notify of

You may also like

Blockchain

CargoSmart, Tesla and Cosco to Pilot Blockchain Tech in Cargo Release Process

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

CargoSmart, the software wing of the Hong Kong-based Orient Overseas Container Line, aims to transform the cargo release process using its new blockchain application.

According to a report published by Splash 247 on April 7, CargoSmart partnered with Cosco,  Shanghai International Port Group (SIPG), and the electric vehicle and clean energy behemoth Tesla to conduct a pilot project for the application.

Digitizing the shipping industry

The traditional documentation processes of the shipping industry are cost and time-intensive, which makes the whole industry less efficient. CargoSmart has been conducting research and development for its application to reduce consignee and shipment agent verification steps. 

The firm aims to digitize the documentation process and reduce the overall time for picking up cargo from shipping terminals and thus reduce delivery times. 

Speaking of how their blockchain-based application would help the shipping industry globally, Cargo Smart stated:

“The…


View More Article
Bitcoin

Bitcoin Has Gained $600 for 3 Consecutive Mondays — Price Hits $7,400

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

Bitcoin (BTC) bulls showed up early Monday morning and took full control of Bitcoin price by sending the price through the $6,900-$7,200 resistance zone to a nearly 4-week high of $7,454. The surge to $7,454 occurred as the United States’ markets opened strong, leading the S&P 500 and Dow to rally 7.03% and 7.73%, respectively. 

It seems investors are beginning to gain some confidence as the rate of novel coronavirus infections begins to slow down in Italy, Spain and China along with murmurs of additional financial stimulus packages from governments. 

Crypto market daily price chart

Crypto market daily price chart. Source: Coin360

BTC price bullish but the future is in flux

Bitcoin’s strong upside move pulled the price above the rising wedge trendline and through the $6,900 level which has functioned as a…

View More Article
Bitcoin

Bitcoin Price Will Go Up as Only Profitable Miners Remain: Data Analyst

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

Approximately 4-weeks ago global equities markets were in distress as investors finally realized that the coronavirus was not just an illness restricted to China, but rather a global pandemic which could permanently damage economics across the globe. 

Crypto markets were not shielded from the mayhem that led the S&P 500 and Dow to post some of the biggest losses since the 2008 global financial crisis and investors will recall that on March 13 Bitcoin (BTC) price dropped more than 50% in the span of 24-hours. 

To date, the volatility and fear within financial markets remain and the future forecast for equities markets is still gloomy but some investors are at least beginning to feel that the absolute worst has passed. 

As is customary in the crypto sector, when a catastrophic event occurs, analysts, traders, soothsayers and crypto Twitter personalities peer through the dust and rubble…

View More Article
Blockchain

What is Prime Brokerage, and Will it Gain Traction in Crypto?

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

From margin trading to futures, many services have made the leap from traditional financial instruments to cryptocurrency. But there’s one that has yet to enter the consciousness of most crypto traders: prime brokerage.

Here, Bequant CEO George Zarya explains why 2020 could be the year that this technology starts to gain momentum, how it’s used across commodities and equities, and what it could deliver to those who currently own digital assets.

1. Can you explain prime brokerage simply? And why isn’t it common in the crypto world?

The main pain point a prime broker is solving for its clients is efficiency of collateral management. This means that clients may access multiple liquidity venues through one window, manage their collateral and settlements efficiently, and have access to leverage based on their overall portfolio, or so-called portfolio margining. 

The crypto world…

View More Article
Blockchain

BitMEX Operator Gives $400K Sponsorship to Cybersecurity Nonprofit

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

HDR Global Trading, the operator of crypto exchange BitMEX, is giving a $400,000 grant to the cybersecurity nonprofit Shadowserver Foundation.

In an April 6 statement on the company’s blog, HDR Global Trading announced that it would offer $400,000 to the organization over the next four years. The BitMEX operator will be acting as a member of the nonprofit’s new industry alliance for Internet security.

Richard Perlotto, Shadowserver Director, thanked HDR for “their rapid response to our call for help” and emphasized the organization’s commitment to fighting cybercrime. The director is referring to IT firm Cisco Systems pulling their support for Shadowserver in February, precipitating a call for new sponsors. 

Samuel Reed, Co-Founder and Chief Technology Officer (CTO) of BitMEX, said:

“Shadowserver is an extremely highly regarded player in the botnet defence community. They work tirelessly and make a…


View More Article
Blockchain

Tezos Co-Founder Hints That Her Trading Card Game Will Use Alternative Blockchain

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

Tezos co-founder Kathleen Breitman has left open the possibility that her trading card game Emergents may not be built on the company’s blockchain, according to statements made on April 5.

According to the Reddit post, Kathleen pointed out that Emergents might not be using Tezos blockchain technology, saying she had not yet decided on the platform she will use in the game.

In a comment left on the post, she added the following:

“The alpha doesn’t have a marketplace, it’s an alpha. The white paper doesn’t describe any feature that could not be satisfied by any other smart contract platform. I have an obligation to my investors to pick a platform with certain properties, and I am not bound to Tezos.”

Emergents was announced in March, as reported by Cointelegraph. It was advertised as a blockchain-based game competitor…


View More Article
Bitcoin

Bitcoin Price Rallies Higher but Must Hit $8K to Start a Bull Market

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

Bitcoin (BTC) closed the week up 15.4% at $6,775 and has started the day with a further 6% move to the upside, breaching the $7,000 handle and making highs at $7,300. 

Looking at performance relative to its peers, Ether (ETH) and EOS have posted an impressive 16% gain over the last 24 hours. As a result, Bitcoin dominance is down 1.5% at 65%.

Crypto market daily price chart. Source: Coin360

The total cryptocurrency market capitalization breached the $200 billion level, breaking from the diagonal resistance dating back to February when the total market value briefly touched $300 billion. 

Total Cryptocurrency Market Capitalization chart. Source:

View More Article
Blockchain

Most of China’s DLT Firms That Closed in 2019 Were Scams or Poorly Planned

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

Most of the blockchain firms that closed in 2019 were cryptocurrency scams or had deficient business models, according to recent research.

Research sent to Cointelegraph by Chinese market research firm EqualOcean on March 26 suggests that most blockchain-backed Chinese businesses that halted their activity last year had major flaws.

Short-lived companies

The report found over 70 blockchain projects that shut their doors last year. Among them over 70% of the projects reportedly did not survive their first year and 30% did not last 6 months. The research reads:

“A considerable number of which were crypto exchanges that involved scams, digital wallets and decentralized applications that used multiple-level marketing, and public blockchains that did not have a defined business model.”

Per the report, “China’s blockchain scene in 2019 was more or less like a slow recovery after a high fever.” Overall, last year China’s…


View More Article