Bitcoin

Bitcoin’s Taproot Upgrade Won’t Help Privacy Where It Matters

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

The activation of Bitcoin’s (BTC) Taproot upgrade is moving forward as official Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIP) were submitted for review on Jan. 24. Even though Taproot is often hyped up for its privacy improvements, its true impact is likely to be very minor.

What is Taproot?

Taproot is the name given to a proposal coined by former Blockstream CTO Gregory Maxwell in January 2018. The actual implementation was later developed by a team of Bitcoin contributors led by Pieter Wuille. Taproot is a proposal that enhances Bitcoin’s scripts, a set of instructions attached to each transaction that explains how the funds can be used.

In its simplest form, a Bitcoin transaction is secured by the recipient’s public key, which guarantees that only he can spend them. Scripts can support more complicated features, like timelocks and multi-signature requirements. The former can restrict money to only be spent after a certain point in time. The latter makes it possible to create wallets with multiple owners.

The conditions can be added together, so that there would be multiple options on how to spend the money. For example, the script might say that the funds can be moved immediately if three people agree, or after five days if only two of them do.

In Bitcoin’s current implementation, the full scope of the smart contract needs to be revealed when its beneficiary wants to use the money. That means that if only one of the conditions was triggered, everyone would know that there were others.

Taproot removes the need to publish the entire script, and only shows the condition that was triggered. In addition, multi-signature contracts where all parties agreed on a transaction can avoid revealing the fact that there was a script at all. To an external observer it would look like an individual wallet-to-wallet transaction, assuming the parties involved are in full cooperation.

This is made possible by a different feature called Schnorr signatures, which is encoded in BIP 340. Schnorr is considered a more secure and efficient version of elliptic curve cryptography, which is what underpins the system driving private and public keys. 

The proposal is currently under evaluation, but there are no estimates available for its activation.

Limited benefits to privacy

Bitcoin is a fully public ledger, which allows specialized tools to track the flow of BTC from one wallet to the next. Thus, a protocol named CoinJoin (CJ) was developed to help break the chain of transactions and provide anonymity.

As it uses a peculiar transaction scheme, it is easy to prove that a certain wallet mixed Bitcoin through CoinJoin. This has recently started to create problems for users. 

As previously reported by Cointelegraph in December, a Binance user was put under investigation for his history of mixing the coins he withdrew from the exchange. A similar case involving Paxos was recently reported by a Twitter user.

Taproot is often mistakenly believed to make CoinJoin transactions harder to see, or even make them indistinguishable from normal payments. In a conversation with Cointelegraph, Pieter Wuille revealed that this is not the case:

“Indeed, it [Taproot] hides scripts and makes multisig (often) indistinguishable. It does not directly do anything for CoinJoin.”

Wuille then added that Taproot is “certainly no silver bullet” for privacy.

The confusion may have arisen due to an initially planned feature called cross-input aggregation. It was later removed from the Taproot proposal due to potential issues from its implementation. Furthermore, Wuille clarified that it would not directly improve privacy:

“Cross-input aggregation won’t hide CJ or anything else. It’s not a privacy improvement, only an efficiency one (which may indirectly encourage CJ by making it cheaper, but even then, it won’t reduce the ability to recognize such transactions as CJ).”

Thus, Taproot only improves privacy in limited aspects and under specific conditions. For a person using Bitcoin to buy drugs from a darknet market, there is no benefit.





Source

Leave a Reply

avatar
  Subscribe  
Notify of

You may also like

Blockchain

South African National Blockchain Alliance Holds Online Launch

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

The South African National Blockchain Alliance carried out an online livestream launch while the country is in the midst of a 21-day lockdown to curb the spread of the coronavirus pandemic. The organization was due to be launched at the beginning of April in Johannesburg but had to be taken online as South Africa and the world tackles a global health crisis.

The launch happened during a livestream on YouTube on April 3, which included a panel of speakers elaborating on how SANBA will help nurture blockchain-focused startups and companies that are developing capabilities using the technology.

Bringing parties together

SANBA has been set up by the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research and its subsidiary, the Office for Digital Advantage. These bodies fall under the jurisdiction of the Department of Science and Innovation.

Akhona Damane heads up the project and said that…


View More Article
Blockchain

150-Year-Old Chinese Gas Company Ramps Up Blockchain Adoption

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

Chinese energy company, Shanghai Gas, announced an expansion of its blockchain efforts following a successful trial partnership with supply chain management blockchain firm, VeChain (VET), on March 31.

Shanghai Gas, founded in 1865, is owned by utility services company, Shenergy Group — which claims to occupy more than 90% of Shanghai’s gas market. The firm has an annual supply of over 8 billion cubic meters.

Shanghai Gas expands blockchain adoption

Shanghai Gas’ trial used distributed ledger technology, or DLT, provided by VeChain to comprehensively monitor its supply chain and identify opportunities for efficiency savings and reduced operational costs.

The expanded partnership will see Shanghai Gas build “a trust-free ‘Energy-as-a-Service’ ecosystem” in partnership with VeChain and electricity provider ENN Energy Holdings.

ENN generates electricity for 17 provinces, more than 16 million residential dwellings, and…


View More Article
Bitcoin

Crypto Traders Allegedly Involved in a $35m Ponzi Scheme

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

Three alleged cryptocurrency traders ran a Ponzi scheme which scammed more than 100 investors for over $35 million, according to a lawsuit filed by an entity formed by the victims in a federal court of Florida, United States.

According to an announcement published on April 2, Q3 Investment Recovery Vehicle, who represents defrauded investors, accused the trio of alleged crypto traders of cheating victims by promising them a winning trading formula. 

Former NYSE and Wells Fargo workers among the accused 

The federal securities fraud case names three individuals as the primary perpetrators of the scheme. They include James Seijas, who worked as a financial advisor for Wells Fargo until March 2019, Quan Tran, a surgeon, and Michael Ackerman, who was a New York Stock Exchange institutional broker. These three are thought to…


View More Article
Blockchain

As Malta Delays Regulatory Clarity, Fewer Firms Remain on ‘Blockchain Island’

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

It seems that Malta is becoming both less popular among and less populated with crypto firms. The European Union country attracted dozens of industry players in 2018 on the back of the “blockchain island” agenda championed by the local government, but the relevant framework has not yet proven to be effective. Meanwhile, the official rhetoric apparently started to shift away from the blockchain sector, as the government now aims to consolidate it with “other niche sectors.”

Meanwhile, the Malta Financial Services Authority, continues to pluck out non-registered crypto agents — be it the world’s top crypto exchange or smaller startups. But in reality, no businesses have been licensed under the blockchain framework yet, despite it being released in the summer of 2018. As a result, a number of companies have decided to leave the island over the past months. So, who is currently…


View More Article
Bitcoin

Bitcoin Bulls Can Take BTC Price to $8K Amid Report $10 Oil Inevitable

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

Bitcoin (BTC) was pushing to flip $7,000 resistance to support on April 3 amid warnings that oil markets really will hit $10 a barrel this month.

Cryptocurrency market daily overview. Source: Coin360

Cryptocurrency market daily overview. Source: Coin360

Media: $10 oil could last the whole Q2

Data from Coin360 and Cointelegraph Markets tracked multiple attempts by Bitcoin bulls to push the market definitively over the $7,000 mark on Thursday and Friday.

At press time, all those attempts had failed to deliver support, with BTC/USD in each case falling back to the high $6,000 range.

Bitcoin 1-day price chart. Source: Coin360

Bitcoin 1-day price chart. Source: Coin360

Bitcoin surged higher earlier on…

View More Article
Blockchain

Bail Bloc Founder Says How Monero Mining Can Help ICE Detainees

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

One cryptocurrency project is using Monero (XMR) to give undocumented immigrants a better shot at a fair treatment in the United States judicial system.

The Bail Bloc project collects cryptocurrency to help people get out of pretrial incarceration for cases with the United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Unlike conventional charities, Bail Bloc doesn’t want your money — it wants your computer processing power.

Cointelegraph reached out to Bail Bloc co-creator Grayson Earle for deeper insight into the initiative.

Detainees make bail with Monero

Users download a special app that uses between 10% and 50% of their overall processor capacity— the user can set the rate — to mine the privacy-oriented cryptocurrency Monero.

Bail Bloc trades its XMR for U.S. dollars every month and then donates the sum on a rotating basis to the bail funds in…


View More Article
Bitcoin

Coronavirus Pandemic Reminds Us That Security Is Important During the Zoom Boom

single-image

bitbond bitcoin lending

Even with all the looming uncertainty surrounding the global COVID-19 pandemic, system security needs to remain at the forefront of companies’ planning. 

Businesses around the world are shutting down under local, state or national decrees as COVID-19 fears bring caution regarding public gatherings. Unsurprisingly, hackers have used the unprecedented opportunity of chaos and panic to probe weaknesses in information technology systems. One of those systems happened to be the United States Department of Health and Human Services, making the act even more egregious, considering the circumstances.

But the problem extends beyond hackers and threats to companies and individuals. During times of crisis, civil liberties also come under threat, and cryptography often provides a shield against unwarranted encroaches by the government.

So, whether you’re a business worried about paying server and security costs during this economic turmoil or…


View More Article