Governments Begin to Roll Out FATF’s Travel Rule Around the Globe


bitbond bitcoin lending

It’s been nearly eight months since the Financial Action Task Force issued its divisive crypto directives, establishing traditional banking regulations within the crypto sector. With the year-long adoption deadline fast approaching, how have the world’s regulatory authorities responded to the guidelines so far?

The FATF — an intergovernmental organization tasked with combating money laundering — found itself at the center of controversy last June after issuing its latest crypto guidance. The directive merged the cryptocurrency industry into existing banking policy, requiring firms to comply with the same requirements as traditional financial institutions.

Among the more notable directives is the travel rule: a requirement for “virtual asset service providers” or VASPs — including crypto exchanges and custodial wallet providers — to disclose customer information when facilitating a trade of $1,000 or higher. The requested information covers both the sender’s and recipient’s name, geographical address and account details.

The directives arose from the FATF’s observation that the “threat of criminal and terrorist misuse of virtual assets” had the potential to develop into a severe problem. In a public statement, the authority stated that it would give its 37 members 12 months to adopt the guidelines. So, with less than five months to go until the FATF’s June review, how are member countries adhering to the directives?

The United States: Ahead of the curve

The U.S. is charged with the conception of the FATF guidance after basing the directives on the Bank Secrecy Act — the country’s primary Anti-Money Laundering law. In 2013, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, or FinCEN, determined that the BSA should apply to the cryptocurrency industry. Within this recommendation, FinCEN also confirmed the application of the BSA travel rule, issuing its own guidance for VASPs in May 2019.

FinCEN has not been shy when it comes to enforcing control. In 2015, the agency slapped cryptocurrency payment protocol Ripple with a $450,000 fine after the firm “willfully violated” BSA rules.

Yet, according to FinCEN Director Kenneth Blanco, the breach of the travel rule is one of the most commonly cited violations — and it often goes unpunished. Speaking to Cointelegraph, Thomas Maxon, head of U.S. operations at blockchain solutions firm CoolBitX, reasoned that a lighter touch might have been exercised to foster U.S. innovation:

“This can be interpreted in two ways: either FinCEN has been lenient and understanding of the crypto industry, giving them time to build compliance solutions, or FinCEN realizing that an enforcement action too early would incentivize many U.S. entities to move their businesses offshore in order to avoid regulatory oversight. The latter is more likely.”

Switzerland takes on the travel rule

As recently reported by Cointelegraph, one of the latest countries to enforce FATF guidance is Switzerland. Last week, the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority lowered the transaction threshold for unidentified crypto exchanges from $5,000 (5,000 CHF) to $1,000 (1,000 CHF). Falling in line with the FATF’s travel rule threshold, the new Financial Services Act aims to address the “heightened money-laundering risks” within the crypto market.

Of course, the FATF’s guidance is just that — guidance. Despite the foreboding June deadline, the directives are advisory and, therefore, not legally enforceable. It’s plausible that Switzerland is merely complying to EU standardization, especially in the wake of the recently imposed Fifth Money Laundering Directive, or 5AMLD.

The EU’s interpretation of FATF directives

The EU’s Fifth Anti-Money Laundering Directive came into force on Jan. 10 and seems to mostly correspond to the FATF guidance. With 27 member states, including Germany, France and — until recently — the United Kingdom, the EU’s implementation of the FATF directives is of enormous significance. However, while an attempt to adopt the directives has clearly been made, the 5AMLD is not as stringent as the FATF’s guidance.

The 5AMLD-attached custodian wallet providers and crypto-to-fiat exchanges to the directive’s list of obliged entities. This introduced the requirement for crypto-to-fiat exchanges to keep a record of customer dealings, as well as to conduct Know Your Customer and AML checks.

However, the distinction between this and the FATF’s guidance lies in the semantics. Crypto-to-crypto exchanges, which fall under the FATFs definition of a “VASP,” aren’t stated on the EU’s list of obliged entities. This indicates that crypto-to-crypto firms are exempt from 5AMLD compliance.

The 5AMLD directives also take a lighter approach to customer recordkeeping. FATF guidance recommends data-gathering on both the recipient and the sender as well as liaising with other VASPs, while the 5AMLD merely entails recordkeeping and the submission of data to financial intelligence organizations upon request.

Interestingly, despite the U.K.’s recent departure from the European Union, the country’s financial sector was compelled to follow the 5AMLD directives, as they came in before the Brexit deadline of Jan. 31.

Consequently, in its role as the U.K.’s AML authority for crypto business, the Financial Conduct Authority announced a new compliance regime. Alongside the standard AML practices, including those derived from 5AMLD, the FCA necessitated all crypto firms to undertake “ongoing monitoring of all customers” — a definitive nod to FATF compliance.

FATF impact around the world

Japan, South Korea and Singapore have been exceptionally receptive to FATF directives. At the end of January, Singapore announced its Payment Services Act 2019. Unlike the EU’s ambiguous 5AMLD definition, the PSA requires “digital payment token” services — which encompasses both crypto businesses and exchanges — to comply with FATF-ready AML rules. In line with FATF guidance, Singapore set its travel rule threshold at around $1000 (SG $1,500).

Related: Singapore AML Framework Can Attract Crypto Businesses, Not Chase It Away

Meanwhile, Japan has always been a keen observer of cryptocurrency regulation. As early as 2017, the government started acknowledging Bitcoin and its crypto derivatives as property within Japan’s Payment Services Act. Moreover, the document calls for domestic crypto firms to comply with AML regulations and register with a competent local finance bureau.

South Korea has also heeded the FATF’s advice, passing a bill back in November 2019 that established a legal structure for cryptocurrencies. The bill introduced an AML framework requiring all crypto-related businesses in South Korea to follow FATF compliance to the letter.

What action is being taken by crypto platforms?

Judging by the sheer volume of travel rule violations, it seems few crypto firms have actually heeded FATF guidance, regardless of the jurisdictional implementation. Maxon — whose company CoolBitX is attempting to ease KYC procedures — takes this one step further, asserting that crypto company compliance in the U.S. is nonexistent: “Not a single major crypto business has actually been compliant on the travel rule despite the applicability of the rule since 2013.”

Nevertheless, over the past few months, there has been an abundance of firms offering compliance solutions, including CipherTrace’s TRISA, Bitcoin Suisse’s OpenVASP, Chainalysis, Elliptic and Netki, among others.

For many, the FATF’s guidance is akin to squeezing a square peg in a round hole. Bob Morris, global chief of compliance for Apifiny — a distributed trading network — believes that the splintered nature of the crypto industry isn’t conducive to existing FATF policy. Speaking to Cointelegraph, Morris opined:

“In the traditional banking industry, the travel rule is feasible because everyone is collaborating across one system. But in the fragmented world of cryptocurrency exchanges, the challenge of devising a successful unified framework is too onerous to succeed — right now, exchanges don’t have a clue as to how to implement it.”

Taking the opposite stance, Reuben Yap, chief operations officer at Zcoin, told Cointelegraph that conventional banking rules could further legitimize the crypto industry, adding:

“It will also help shake the perception that cryptocurrency is used to facilitate illegal activity given that it will be now subject to the same rules as fiat.”

However, Yap cautioned that additional compliance costs may sound the death knell for smaller firms. Thomas Glucksmann, vice president of global development at blockchain analytic firm Merkle Science, shared a similar opinion to Yap’s, suggesting that faith from governments and regulators will eventually foster industry growth:

“Over the long term better information sharing between institutions provides more trust and confidence in the industry’s ability to combat money laundering and other criminal activity, which hopefully results in better relationships with banks and regulators to facilitate wider adoption of cryptocurrency.”

In the same vein, CipherTrace chief financial analyst John Jefferies claims that added scrutiny will help mature the cryptocurrency asset class, even though in the short-term, “VASPs will likely incur additional expenses as they seek to comply with the Travel Rule.” He went on to add:

“Some VASPs may cease to exist or others such as Deribit may move to unregulated countries such as Panama. It will be good for the industry in the mid and long term because the Travel Rule will help virtual assets grow into an asset class that is safe for investors.”

The (not-so-massive) impact on privacy coins

Still, one crucial question remains: Do the FATF directives pose a risk to privacy coins? Following the FATF guidance, exchanges such as Coinbase and OKEx started booting privacy coins in an effort to comply. This, Yap says, arises from a “misunderstanding” of the travel rule. According to him, privacy coins face the same trials as any other cryptocurrency, as travel rule compliance occurs off-chain:

“Whether a coin has privacy features or not does not affect its compliance with the Travel Rule since a VASP can always give information of its transactions with other VASPs since it already has the customer’s identity and KYC.”

Indeed, developers of privacy coins contend that their protocols are still able to submit to FATF directives. For instance, the crew behind Beam — a cryptocurrency based on the confidential transaction protocol MimbleWimble — have already taken steps to offer a transaction auditability feature.

Glucksmann explained that protocols such as these allow for privacy coins to continue unimpeded, “Exchanges and other cryptocurrency businesses can support these privacy coins while still complying with regulatory requirements.” However, Jefferies noted that additional privacy layers in major cryptocurrencies may add to compliance difficulties:

“Major tokens including Bitcoin and Ethereum are adding privacy layers so VASPs and regulators need to understand and mitigate the compliance risks. As central bank cryptocurrencies are introduced, privacy will play a critical role in their acceptance in countries that value privacy.”

For better or worse, the FATF guidance has at least prompted several member nations to advance cryptocurrency regulation. Arguably — even at its worst — regulation adds assurances that can help bolster industry legitimacy. While a few remain diametrically opposed to what they consider ill-fitting guidance, the positive impact on the industry could conceivably outweigh the short-term drawbacks.


Leave a Reply

Notify of

You may also like




bitbond bitcoin lending

Binance CEO Changpeng Zhao believes that the upcoming Bitcoin halving has not been priced in to the digital asset’s current price action. The reduction in miner rewards will increase the cost of mining each Bitcoin, meaning, miners are unlikely to sell below their cost of production. 

Bitcoin’s supply will decrease with the halving but its demand has also been increasing, creating a situation where prices are likely to driven higher. Although CZ’s statement can be interpreted as bullish, the CEO personally believes that Bitcoin’s price might gravitate around $10,000 levels for a few more days as round numbers are known to act as psychological barriers.  

The traded volumes in major cryptocurrencies have skyrocketed in the past year and this shows greater participation by the traders. Currently, Tether (USDT) is the most frequently traded crypto asset, followed by Bitcoin and Ether (ETH). Liquidity…

View More Article

Vitalik Buterin Reveals Ethereum 2.0 Roadmap to Cointelegraph


bitbond bitcoin lending

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin discussed plans for Ethereum 2.0 during an exclusive interview with Cointelegraph on Feb.19 at the Stanford Blockchain Conference. Buterin explained that the major development for ETH 2.0 over the course of this year is the launch of Phase 0. He said:

“Phase 0 is the first phase of the Ethereum 2.0 launch. This will release the proof-of-stake network, which will come online this year.”

While the official launch date of Phase 0 is still unknown, Buterin explained that Phase 0 is close to having a multi-client testnet and audits of the existing code. He noted:

“A lot of optimization is currently underway with Phase 0, which we will continue to refine over the next few months.”

Ethereum 2.0 roadmap

Following the launch of Phase 0, Buterin stated that ETH 2.0 will begin as an independent PoS network. He explained that the purpose behind this…

View More Article

Irish Drug Dealer Tells Police That Keys to $56M in Confiscated BTC Are Lost


bitbond bitcoin lending

Dubliner Clifton Collins, who was recently imprisoned for drug trafficking, claims that robbers took the keys to the $56 million in Bitcoin (BTC) Irish High Court had ruled should be confiscated.

After obtaining more than 6,000 BTC by 2017, Collins decided to insure himself against hackers by distributing the cryptocurrency across 12 newly created accounts. Thus, he transferred 500 BTC into each of them, the Irish Times reported on Feb. 21. As of press time, that would leave each wallet worth roughly $4.87 million.

A punishment for his own stupidity?

Collins then printed out the keys for all of his 12 BTC accounts onto a piece of paper, which he says he stored in an aluminium cap of his fishing rod case. This he stored in a house which he rented in County Galway, Ireland. However, when he was arrested for…

View More Article

Bitcoin’s Lightning Network Found More Centralized Than Expected by Researchers


bitbond bitcoin lending

The Lightning Network’s (LN) configuration is becoming increasingly centralized, with multiple hubs being formed. This is the finding of a yet-to-be-reviewed research paper, released on pre-print site arXiv on Feb. 7.

A team of academics from Switzerland, France, Italy and Canada authored the paper. Jian Hong-Lin and Kevin Primicerio conducted the analysis, while others, including Blockstream Inc. researcher Christian Decker, designed the research.

Core-periphery model

The team gathered Lightning Network information for a period of 18 months from Jan. 18, 2018 to July 13, 2019. Researchers then analyzed the payment network in terms of its node and wealth distribution.

They discovered that the network showed high Gini coefficients both in terms of node centralization and wealth distribution. Notably, the values were found to rise as more nodes were added.

The distributions of Bitcoin (BTC) across every node in the network was found to be extremely…

View More Article

Riot’s Stock Dips 5% as It Focuses on Bitcoin Mining Ahead of Halving


bitbond bitcoin lending

Riot Blockchain, a Nasdaq-listed crypto firm in the United States, plans to sell its exchange to focus on Bitcoin (BTC) mining ahead of the halving.

According to an official announcement on Feb. 20, Riot has “opted to sunset further development of Riot’s U.S.-based digital currency exchange” in order to focus on cryptocurrency mining as part of its updated strategic priorities for 2020.

Following the announcement to shift its focus on Bitcoin mining, the company’s shares dropped more than 5%, trading at $1.40 at press time, according to CNBC data.

Industry experts disagree on the potential price impact of May 2020 Bitcoin halving — an event which will decrease block rewards on the Bitcoin blockchain. Changpeng Zhao, the CEO of major crypto exchange Binance, recently predicted that, since miners will have to…

View More Article

Cyprus SEC Embraces Blockchain Despite Unregulated Status of Crypto


bitbond bitcoin lending

The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) recently published a report discussing the ongoing activities of its Innovation Hub — a cooperative entity that was launched in October 2018 as a platform for engagement between CySEC and entities operating in the fintech and regtech sectors. 

Nineteen different companies directly engage with the platform, nine of which comprised projects utilizing blockchain. Among these companies were several projects using distributed ledger technology (DLT) to transfer and verify ownership of financial instruments, trading facilities that operate using blockchain, and a venture capital fund investing in virtual currency startups.

The Hub is intended to facilitate knowledge-sharing between regulators and innovators, promote the development of regulations that foster innovation, and ensure compliance within dynamic and emerging tech industries. It also engages with third parties seeking to participate with emerging financial…

View More Article

Expert Says New Blockchain Regulation Should ‘Nudge’ Rather Than Push


bitbond bitcoin lending

Regulators should aim to influence public behavior rather than rule with an iron fist when it comes to emerging industries such as blockchain.

Two Israel-based academics, Hada Jabotinsky and Nassim Cohen argued this point in a new paper and accompanying brief, published to the University of Oxford Law Department blog on Feb. 21.

The paper proposes an approach that would result neither in an under-regulated free-for-all that leaves consumers vulnerable, nor in heavy-handed prohibitions that stifle technological progress.

Complex new technologies such as blockchain, cryptocurrencies, Internet of Things, and automated cars require ever higher levels of technological literacy. The paper states that, as the pace of innovation gathers speed, regulators struggle to grasp the implications of the products and inventions brought before them. 

What does a “nudge” involve?

The authors argue, “A nudge is ‘any aspect of the…

View More Article

Bitcoin Price Drop Mirrors Last Golden Cross Which Led to 170% Gains


bitbond bitcoin lending

Bitcoin (BTC) may not see a 170% increase after its fifth “golden cross” price event, historical data suggests as markets stay down 8%.

Analysis of price movements since 2009 shows Bitcoin has had a total of ten “golden cross” and “death cross” moments in its lifespan. 

BTC price dip challenges December 2017

A “golden cross” is when BTC/USD sees its 50-day moving average rise to cross over its 200-day moving average. A “death cross” is the opposite. 

As Cointelegraph reported, hopes are currently high that the most recent golden cross will spark an identical reaction to the previous one — a 170% price surge in just two months. 

Overall, however, two out of four golden crosses have resulted in gains, while the other two in fact saw price losses. Similarly, some death crosses were followed by price gains.

Bitcoin traders continue to dig for answers after BTC/USD abruptly dropped $1,000 in…

View More Article